
BIS annual economic report argues stablecoins on public blockchains lack redeemability, liquidity elasticity, and monetary sovereignty protection. Proposes unified ledger with central bank reserves as foundation.
The Bank for International Settlements published its Annual Economic Report on June 23, devoting a full chapter to the argument that stablecoins lack the monetary properties needed to work as reliable payment instruments. The core problem, the report states, is something called “singleness” – the ability to redeem a token at par with central bank money.
Frank Smets and Gaston Gelos, who co-authored Chapter III, lay out a methodical case against the current stablecoin architecture. Gelos, Deputy Head of the Monetary and Economic Department at the BIS, put it bluntly in a Reuters podcast: “stablecoins and other tokens depend on the stability that central banks provide in order to function smoothly.”
The report identifies four structural deficiencies in stablecoins that operate on public, permissionless blockchains. Redeemability at face value isn't always guaranteed, and the supply can't expand or contract during market stress the way central bank money does. Different stablecoin ecosystems still can't easily transact with each other. And open blockchains remain vulnerable to financial crime, the report says.
The BIS warns that widespread adoption of USD-denominated stablecoins could undermine monetary sovereignty in emerging markets. A separate risk sits closer to home for banks: if depositors shift funds from bank accounts into stablecoins, banks lose a cheap funding source and might have to pull back on credit. The BIS projects the overall hit to economic growth would be modest.
Instead of letting stablecoins run on unbacked rails, the BIS proposes a “unified ledger” – a system where tokenized central bank reserves sit at the foundation, providing the singleness guarantee that stablecoins now lack. Commercial banks and other regulated entities would issue tokenized deposits and payment instruments on top of those reserves. That keeps the two-tier monetary structure intact while adding programmability and atomic settlement.
The report points to Project Agora, a BIS innovation hub initiative, as an example of this approach in practice. It also pushes for coordinated regulatory measures targeting the existing stablecoin market. For anyone holding USDT or USDC, the message is that the BIS sees tokenized deposits on central bank infrastructure as the safer path, not the current crop of private coins.
The BIS's argument matters because it comes from the institution that sets standards for the world's central banks. Whether regulators adopt the unified ledger framework or tighten rules on existing stablecoins, the direction of travel is clear: stablecoins will need to prove they can maintain singleness without central bank support, or they will be folded into a system that provides it.
Prepared with AlphaScala research tooling and grounded in primary market data: live prices, fundamentals, SEC filings, hedge-fund holdings, and insider activity. Each story is checked against AlphaScala publishing rules before release. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.