Stocks● Neutral
The NRI guilt trap: why high salaries abroad don't always create wealth
Ajay Pruthi explains how survivor's guilt drives NRIs to send money home, draining savings and trapping them in high-earning jobs abroad.
Continue with
When a young Indian moves to the US, UK, Canada or the Gulf, the assumption back home is that earning in dollars or pounds equals instant wealth. Ajay Pruthi, a Sebi-registered investment advisor and founder of PLNR, argues the reality is different. High earnings often fail to translate into high personal wealth because of what he calls the "guilt tax."
The psychology starts with survivor's guilt. NRIs enjoy better infrastructure and pay while aging parents face daily challenges in India. Unable to be present physically, they compensate with money. "Money becomes a substitute for presence," Pruthi writes. This guilt tax is culturally enforced, not legally demanded. NRIs become the informal financial safety net for their extended family.
The financial damage is clear. Building wealth requires putting earnings into assets that grow over time: mutual funds and real estate. The guilt tax forces money into dead assets or consumption. Many NRIs live paycheck to paycheck despite large salaries. Surplus cash leaks across borders.