
From Brazil to South Korea, 97% of Brazilian day traders and 75% of South Korean retail futures traders lost money, mirroring India's 91% F&O loss rate, SEBI said.
Indian retail traders are not alone in losing money on derivatives. A review of international studies by the Securities and Exchange Board of India found that retail participants in derivatives and other leveraged products consistently lose money across markets, from Brazil to South Korea.
In Brazil, a study of individuals who began day trading equity-index futures found that 97% of those who continued for more than 300 days made a net loss. Only 1.1% earned more than the country's minimum wage from the activity. The study also found that staying in the market longer did not improve outcomes.
South Korean research showed that roughly 75% of retail day traders in KOSPI 200 futures lost money after fees. Higher trading intensity was linked to worse outcomes.
In Taiwan, individual futures traders incurred average losses of NT$61,500 after transaction costs. Greater experience did not translate into better trading skills or lower losses.
European markets reported loss rates of 74% to 89% among retail contract for difference (CFD) accounts. An earlier UK study put the figure at 82%. In France, more than 89% of retail investors lost money in CFD and forex trading over a four-year period. A CFD is similar to an F&O bet between a trader and a broker on whether the price of an asset goes up or down.
In Australia, 68% of retail CFD investors lost money in FY2024, including losses from trading fees. US regulatory data shows about two out of three retail forex accounts typically lose money in a quarter.
SEBI's own data for India shows similar patterns. Around 91% of individual traders in India's equity derivatives segment incurred net losses during FY25-FY26, with cumulative losses exceeding ₹2 lakh crore. Even after aggregate losses moderated to 87.7% in FY26, the proportion of losing traders remained high. More than 1.2 crore unique individuals traded in the segment over the two years.
"International evidence consistently indicates that retail investors globally incur losses when trading derivatives and other leveraged products," SEBI said. "Across jurisdictions, both transaction-level academic studies and regulatory analyses of retail accounts report high loss rates among individual participants in futures, options, CFDs, and foreign-exchange markets."
SEBI also found that trading experience did not materially improve outcomes in India. The probability of losses remained high even after several consecutive years of participation. Higher trading intensity was consistently associated with higher loss rates and larger losses.
"Like in many other jurisdictions, losses remain the dominant outcome for individual traders in the equity derivatives segment in India," the regulator said.
Prepared with AlphaScala editorial tooling from the source reporting linked above. Indexable analysis may include a cited Alpha Score value. Publishing checks screen each story before release. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.