
Judge ordered the £9.54 million interim payment by Aug. 28 on an indemnity basis after the privacy case was dismissed as relying on speculative allegations. The claimants face a total legal bill of £34.5 million.
LONDON, Aug 22 (AlphaScala) – A British judge ordered Prince Harry, singer Elton John and five other claimants to pay £9.54 million in interim legal costs to Daily Mail publisher Associated Newspapers, a decisive financial penalty after their privacy lawsuit collapsed last month.
Justice Matthew Nicklin’s costs order, published Friday, requires the payment by August 28. The judge directed that the costs be paid on an indemnity basis, meaning Associated does not have to prove the expenses were reasonable or proportionate.
The ruling deepens a legal defeat for Harry, 41, who spent months in court accusing the Mail titles of phone hacking and other unlawful information-gathering. Nicklin rejected the case in July after an 11-week trial, saying the claimants relied on “speculative and inferential” allegations and had not withdrawn them when they were no longer actively pursued.
“In my judgment, the cumulative effect of these matters takes the case well outside the norm. The conduct was unreasonable to a high degree,” Nicklin wrote in the costs ruling.
Associated's total legal bill hit £34.5 million ($45.8 million), the court was told in July. Harry and the other claimants held an insurance policy covering just £16 million, leaving the group to cover the difference from personal funds.
Anthony White, Associated's lawyer, argued the claimants had made wide-ranging and serious allegations without supporting evidence, driving up legal costs. The claimants' barrister, Nicholas Bacon, called the £34.5 million figure “eye-watering” and said it exceeded an agreed budget.
A spokesman for Associated called the ruling “another overwhelming victory for the Mail and its journalism.” A representative for Harry did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The full costs bill is not yet settled. If the two sides cannot reach an agreement, the total will be determined in separate proceedings.
The defeat marks a reversal for the prince, who had won a case against the Daily Mirror publisher and settled a claim with Rupert Murdoch's British newspaper arm. He has long blamed the press for the 1997 Paris car crash that killed his mother, Princess Diana, and said in court testimony this year that the Daily Mail had made his wife Meghan's life “an absolute misery.”
Harry stepped down from royal duties in 2020 and moved to California with his family. Days before the costs ruling, news emerged that he and Meghan plan to return to live in Britain with their two children.
No decision has been announced on whether the claimants will appeal the July ruling.
Prepared with AlphaScala editorial tooling from the source reporting linked above. Indexable analysis may include a cited Alpha Score value. Publishing checks screen each story before release. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.