Stocks● Neutral
Pentagon's Kelly Demotion Bid Tests Free Speech for Retirees
Legal experts call the Pentagon's attempt to demote Sen. Mark Kelly over a lawful-orders video legally dead. The move may still deter other veterans from speaking out.
Continue with
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth's attempt to demote retired Navy captain and Senator Mark Kelly over a video statement about lawful orders is legally vulnerable but politically pointed, legal experts said. The order has little chance of surviving a court challenge, yet it may still chill other veterans from speaking out.
“It's dead on arrival,” Gene Fidell, an expert on the Uniform Code of Military Justice at Yale Law School, told the press. “If this ever gets in front of a judge, the judge is going to say, 'Fuck you.'”
Hegseth announced on X that Kelly was being demoted for a November video in which he and five other Democratic lawmakers reiterated that service members do not have to follow unlawful orders. That statement is a banal recitation of existing law, experts said. Hegseth himself has made the same point publicly in past years.
“There's nothing improper, much less criminal, in what they said,” Fidell said. “It's not conduct unbecoming; it is not seditious.”
Brenner Fissell, a law professor at Villanova and vice president of the National Institute of Military Justice, said the video was “merely a statement of the law, which is: You can disobey unlawful orders. That's factually, legally correct. How can it be a criminal offense to state the law?”
Retiree jurisdiction. The Uniform Code of Military Justice applies to retired service members, allowing demotion after retirement for conduct that occurred while in uniform. That power is usually reserved for misconduct like sexual abuse, not political speech. Kelly's statements were made as a civilian senator, not on active duty.