
Tomato season calls for yemista: Greek tomatoes stuffed with rice, beef, and herbs. My dad's recipe is light, healthy, and the perfect summer dinner.
Tomato season is here, and my dad has the perfect dish for it.
He loves whipping up yemista – tomatoes stuffed with a mixture of rice, ground beef, and herbs. The dish is light, healthy, and comforting. It's why I always request it when I visit my parents.
The word yemista means "stuffed" in Greek. Traditionally, the dish combines tomatoes and bell peppers with rice and ground beef, baked in the oven.
Yemista (also spelled gemista) was a weekly staple of my childhood. My parents immigrated to the US from Greece in the 1980s and loved making the dishes they grew up with. Their food helped me connect to my culture as a first-generation Greek American. It instilled an early and enduring love for Mediterranean cooking.
My dad, an excellent home cook, has taught me how to make many classic Greek dishes. He thinks his yemista is a perfect summer dinner.
Yemista is traditionally made with both tomatoes and bell peppers. My dad has found that bell peppers in the US are thicker than in Greece. They are trickier to cook evenly with tomatoes. Now he usually just makes yemista with tomatoes. The process for peppers is the same. Feel free to follow these instructions and try both if you desire.
After washing your tomatoes, use a good knife and slice off the top of each one, including the stem. Don't throw the tops away. You'll need them again before the tomatoes go into the oven.
Scoop out the tomato's core and flesh, leaving enough space to add the yemista filling. My dad recommends using an ice cream scooper since it's sharper. A spoon will also work.
If you're making eight stuffed tomatoes, save the flesh of five of them in a bowl. You'll need them for the filling. My dad recommends using the leftover flesh to make a simple tomato sauce for pasta.
If you're doing stuffed bell peppers as well, scoop them out the same way. Just make sure to throw the seeds away.
Using a knife, remove the hard core from each small ball of tomato filling you've scooped out. Put the remaining flesh in a food processor to finely chop everything.
Carefully slide your ball of tomato filling up and down the grater over a bowl, removing the flesh from the core. Don't try to grate the hard core. We only need the soft part of each tomato. This can be a little trickier, especially for an inexperienced chef, so watch out for your fingers.
Set it aside until it's time to make the filling.
Dump any extra water from the tomato cups right into the baking dish.
Our yemista is almost ready for the oven.
First, add a drizzle of olive oil to a large sauté pan over medium heat. The onion should cook for a couple of minutes, until browned.
Season the beef with salt and freshly ground black pepper for extra flavor. Only use half of the parsley you've prepped.
Use a spatula or wooden spoon to break up the ground beef, cooking it until the meat has browned. This will take around five minutes, until most of the water in the sauce has reduced. Don't let the filling get too dry. We need some liquid to help the rice cook in the oven.
Give it one last mix, and your filling is done.
Remember, the rice will expand in the oven. Make sure you don't overfill the cups.
Depending on the size of your tomatoes, you might have some extra filling. Since it contains raw rice, there's not much you can do with it. If you have extra tomatoes, you can always scoop them out and fill them with the extra stuffing. Or adjust your recipe next time to use less ground beef.
Add half a cup of water to the pan, along with a spoonful of olive oil. Both help prevent the tomato cups from sticking to the pan.
Place the baking dish on the middle rack of your oven, set to 360 degrees Fahrenheit. It takes about 1 hour and 15 minutes to 1 hour and 30 minutes to cook the yemista, depending on the oven. Check on them around the 45-minute mark.
Scoop a bit of the stuffing from a tomato and taste it to see if the rice is cooked. If it still tastes chewy or crispy, the yemista needs more baking time.
This helps the yemista cool and absorb all those delicious flavors you worked so hard on.
Season the stuffed tomatoes with some oregano and freshly cracked black pepper. You can also serve them topped with a yogurt-and-garlic sauce, just like my grandfather always loved.
To make the sauce, take one cup of Greek yogurt and add a minced clove of garlic. Mix everything together, then add a teaspoon or more on top of each stuffed tomato, depending on your preference.
Yemista also goes great with my dad's Greek potatoes.
Yemista is perfect for the summer, when tomatoes are at their peak. I love the blistered texture of the roasted tomatoes, which are juicy and subtly sweet. The combination of the rice and beef is always comforting. The dish is colorful and healthy – a hallmark of the Mediterranean diet beloved by Greeks.
When I was a kid and my parents made yemista with both tomatoes and peppers, I never ate the pepper shells. I always asked for more tomatoes. My best friend, Nausheen, would always request it whenever she came over for dinner in high school. She still talks about it to this day.
Whenever you decide to eat it, I hope my dad's yemista brings you as much joy and comfort as it has given me through the decades.
Drafted by a large language model from the source reporting linked above, then screened by automated publishing checks. It is not read by a journalist before publication. Some articles cite our Alpha Score. Verify prices and figures against the original source. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.