False declines cost U.S. merchants $157B annually and push 42% of shoppers to abandon carts. Real-time payment decisioning is the fix.
Alpha Score of 61 reflects moderate overall profile with moderate momentum, strong value, moderate quality, moderate sentiment.
About one in five eCommerce orders fails globally, and U.S. merchants lose roughly $157 billion a year to false declines, according to PYMNTS Intelligence's payments tracker series, produced with PayPal Open, the payments platform from PayPal. The same data puts global revenue leakage at about $47 billion a year and shows that 42% of consumers abandon a purchase after a rejected payment.
The tracker series argues those failures are no longer a processing issue. Authorization, routing, cost management and fraud prevention are converging into a single real-time decisioning layer. Merchants that used core orchestration capabilities, including routing automation and network tokens, posted approval rates above 97%, compared with 32% of merchants relying on manual routing.
Historically, merchants treated authorization, fraud, routing and processing costs as separate operating problems. Fraud teams dictated risk rules, payments teams managed acquirer relationships, finance departments tracked fees and engineering teams tuned checkout performance. The report said that separation is breaking down.
Commerce now spans cards, wallets, account-to-account rails, local payment methods and multiple acquirers. The hard part, the report said, is no longer transporting the transaction. It is deciding in milliseconds which credential to use and how much risk to accept.
Adjusting any one variable in isolation can worsen the overall result, the report said. Routing to a different acquirer may lift approval rates. The same routing decision can raise processing cost. Tightening a fraud rule may cut losses. It can also reject profitable customers.
The payoff from closing the gap is concrete. Moving a large merchant from a 92% approval rate to 96% can recover millions of dollars in sales without adding a single new customer, according to the tracker. That is the revenue hiding behind the decline button.
Fraud prevention is being reframed the same way. Anti-fraud measures contribute to customer churn at 56% of U.S. retailers and 54% of U.S. eCommerce companies, the report found. The report also found that 85% of U.S. merchants described preventing fraud without damaging the customer experience as their biggest challenge. The goal, the report said, is not simply to stop more fraud. It is to determine which transactions can be safely approved.
AI-driven risk systems are moving closer to the authorization layer, the report said. Behavioral and network signals can inform a decision in real time, rather than through static rules applied independently of payment performance.
The broader consequence, the report said, is that payments infrastructure is moving upstream in commercial strategy. The next generation of platforms is being designed less like a transaction processor and more like a decision engine, weighing approval rates against routing costs and fraud exposure. The report frames the gap between current approval rates and achievable ones as the opportunity.
The full study, 'The Performance Gap: Why Every Transaction Is a Growth Opportunity,' was released with the August edition of the PYMNTS Intelligence tracker series.
Drafted by a large language model from the source reporting linked above, then screened by automated publishing checks. It is not read by a journalist before publication. Some articles cite our Alpha Score. Verify prices and figures against the original source. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.