
Shruti Desai, who said she briefly taught Pednekar at a Mumbai film school, questioned her 'world-view' change; the actress has not replied.
Bhumi Pednekar's former teacher has accused the actress of being disrespectful toward her instructors during acting training, adding a personal layer to the backlash Pednekar already faces over her comments on the NEET-UG protests.
Shruti Desai, a spiritual psychotherapist who said she briefly taught Pednekar at a Mumbai film school, posted the claim on Instagram and tagged the actress. Desai recalled Pednekar being "disrespectful, almost disdainful" about her teachers and questioned how her worldview had changed since then.
"Care to explain your new approach towards the concepts of respect and responsibility and how your world-view changed so drastically in the interim?" Desai wrote.
Reactions to the post were divided. Some users backed Desai. "My favourite part about this post is the fact that a female educator is asking an educated female for accountability," one wrote. Others questioned the framing. "It says film school. Can y'all read? She was not a child in film school," another commented. "I hope Shruti's teacher also commented about how Shruti was when she was 15!!" a third user wrote. One supporter added, "Shruti, I am so proud to call you my friend, bravo bravo!" Another user said Pednekar appeared to be the same person staff on The Kapil Sharma Show had described multiple times.
The exchange sits on top of a wider controversy. Pednekar had posted videos criticising offensive slogans directed at Prime Minister Narendra Modi during the protests over the NEET-UG exam, the medical entrance test that has drawn students into the streets across India. She argued that disrespectful language toward constitutional offices was unacceptable and called for civil dialogue over personal attacks.
Critics, many of them younger users, accused her of presenting one side of the story. They noted she had not commented on the alleged police action during the 20 July protest, including the lathi charge and the use of tear gas. That event has become the reference point for the criticism.
Pednekar defended her position in the videos. "Everything has descended into abuse and name-calling… You are speaking about someone who occupies the highest office in our country today. And, this is not just about the office. Would we speak to the elders in our own families with such abusive language? Guys, this is not our culture. This is wrong," she said.
"This has been bothering me deeply, and that's why I wanted to come out and address it," she added.
Desai's post is a personal charge, not a comment on the protest issue itself. It reaches Pednekar at a point where the public dispute has already moved past her original statement. Critics have framed the backlash around what she did not say, pointing to the police response during the protest. The teacher's account adds a separate question about her conduct years earlier. The claim is a recollection from a brief period, with no corroborating detail, which is part of why the thread has split so evenly. What began as a video about the language of protest has widened into a dispute about the actress's credibility.
Pednekar has not responded publicly to Desai's post.
Drafted by a large language model from the source reporting linked above, then screened by automated publishing checks. It is not read by a journalist before publication. Some articles cite our Alpha Score. Verify prices and figures against the original source. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.