
New CMO Council report finds 73% of marketing teams with integrated AI-human workflows report above-expectation ROI. First American's brand chief explains why human creativity remains the differentiator.
Seventy-three percent of marketing organizations that redesigned their workflows around AI-human collaboration report measurable or above-expectation ROI. Among firms with little integration, that figure drops to 22%, according to the CMO Council's new report, Marketing's Power Partner: AI and the Human Essence.
The report surveyed 371 global marketing leaders and included interviews with brands like First American, DBS Bank, Orange Business and Gap Inc. It examines the change from treating AI as a simple productivity layer to redesigning entire marketing operations around collaboration between humans and machines.
Stephen Shultz, vice president of brand marketing at First American, describes the 136-year-old financial institution's approach. The marketing team trains AI tools on the company's brand, market perspective and customer research data. Insights flow across teams to inform strategy. Shultz calls AI a "digital partner" that handles the deep research marketers rarely have time to do on their own.
Marketing teams use synthetic customer personas to test assumptions before campaigns reach real audiences. AI scans competitor positioning. The technology identifies patterns and opportunities. Shultz says the creative leap still belongs to humans. "AI can tell us what's typical," Shultz says. "Human creativity tells us what's possible. The difference between those two defines great marketing."
Internally, Shultz's group builds AI-powered assistants to help marketers plan and train more efficiently. The tools also handle measurement. For lean teams, he says, it offers a significant advantage. "AI helps us scale what we can deliver without sacrificing the quality of the thinking or the creativity behind it."
Shultz also notes a less obvious benefit. AI can be asked to act as a skeptical CFO, helping identify the financial metrics that best demonstrate campaign impact. "It enables everybody to scale up their capabilities," he says.
The report's broader finding: AI accelerates iteration and decision-making. The real differentiator is human judgment. Without it, Shultz warns, "you're just accelerating toward the average."
Prepared with AlphaScala editorial tooling from the source reporting linked above. Indexable analysis may include a cited Alpha Score value. Publishing checks screen each story before release. Educational coverage, not personalized advice.